I love that shot of your winch going under water...
Must have been blowing pretty good that day or at least gusting pretty good.
I recently started a subscription for WoodenBoat magazine and was also checking out their forum. And you are certainly right that there is not a concensus on the epoxy under the varnish debate.
For my choice of poison I think the epoxy makes sense. If you look at wood under a very high magnification it is like a bundle of straws. Those straws are what wicked up the moisture and nutrients from the ground to feed the tree when it was alive. They are very good at wicking up moisture. And wood expands and contracts in large part based on the amount of moisture it is taking on or giving off which it does throughout its existence. So I believe if I limit the amount of moisture the wood can wick up (I will never stop it completely) then I can limit the amount of expansion and contraction that eventually causes the finish to fail. At least that is my take on the subject.
I checked out the Epifanes website briefly but was unable to decifer if the rapid coat was a better or not as good of a UV blocker than the original Epifanes varnish. I will need to spend some more time reading more about the two products. I guess in my mind which ever is the better UV blocker will be the choice I go with. Even if it takes me longer to do the finishing. I'm guessing that will turn out to be the original slow drying material.
1 Attachment(s)
Cpete I don't know how well this picture will turn out but
this is 3 coats of Cetol natural teak on mahogany. It was brushed on about 1-1/2 years ago and has been laying in my shop ever since. You can probably tell it looks lots better than the older versions with the redish stain they have... problem is it does not protect like the older versions either.
I really wished there was a water based finish that worked well in the marine enviroment like the water based polyurethane I put on the worktop this sample is laying on. The worktop is a large U shape with 5 ft legs and a 14ft bottom of the U and in a single day I sprayed 8 coats of the water based poly on it. By the time I got to the far end the end I started on was dry to the touch and in another 20 to 30 minutes I could sand it.
100 opinions = 1,000 toes to step on!
Here's a Florida based pro varnisher who works in humidity and heat.
Since most varnishing anywhere will be attempted at better weather moments,
Vicente Williams has some very interesting tricks to reveal...
google Varnish Teak
http://varnishteak.blogspot.com
He mentions, but doesn't quote, Rebecca Wittman, who wrote the book on the subject.
Doesn't need to, actually.
He prefers to work outdoors.
My caution is to professionally respect the volatile solvents
that are part & parcel of traditional corporate varnish products we have accepted into our life.
Thinners, reducers, driers, de-greasers can shorten your varnish days
- and bestow upon you, not only lasting gloss,
but quality of living problems.
There are 4 blogs in this collection, all interesting!
waterborne clear wood filler
Have Honduras for the coamings, want them done up in an oil varnish, enhanced
with a glow like one of those fabulous fiery red mahogany Interlux filler/stains the
Varnish-Love Club guys use. Sworn off petro now - no more volatile chemicals. The
mahogany has myriad grain lines to fill. Will not be using the dirty brown oil grain filler
- seen on the Furniture Masters site, way too gloomy for my taste - anyway.
Not as easy: AquaCoat waterborne clear gel filler on a hot dye may be the answer.
It's not an exterior product...but onsite photos show some woodworkers use it on
outdoor furniture projects. Doesn't prove anything - unless it's been there ten years.
There is no transparent dye/stain that will not fade in sunlight. Some of the best
metallic waterborne aniline dyes last longer than others, but still must consider it
'interior'. Sunlight through a window will fade and degrade any organic object inside
a room. Varnished mahogany on the water is pretty ridiculous anyway, thinking
about it. Never saw no outdoor grand piano....or varnished ChrisCraft swinging
on a mooring. We do it anyway - do it for the WOW! - if nothing else, ten frickin
coats will delay the mahogany from bleaching blond . Maybe...one more season.
Expect this new clear filler will do fine. Am also guinea pig for a 100% LeTonkinois
varnish job, which has no added material to make it more resistant to UV. Am
persuaded that waterproofing the coamings is the most important first step.
Epoxy encapsulation stays healthy under varnish as long as it's there to protect it
from UV. Waterproofing is the best protection we have for ALL exposed wood.
Clear coats: damned if you do, damned if you don't. "Time for another coat, McDuff!"
The 'tech' I spoke with second time, turns out he is proprietor of AquaCoat....Brian.
Cool! Good guy... fending off this curmudgeon. Ordered a couple qts of AquaCoat
filler, but have to wait until the weather gets above freezing for it to ship.
Want to play around with his red mahogany waterborne dye. He says the dye is the
best metallic aniline - we know waterborne dyes penetrate deeper than all others,
including alcohol. Couple qts UPS. Possible to add J.E.Moser powder to kick the color...
I asked.
Like this: After final sanding, want to dye the bare mahogany first, before anything
else. Asked what he thought, if I then seal with 2 coats of clear laminating epoxy?
{Lightly sand - then fill the remaining grain with AquaCoat clear filler. Sand again
for tooth to varnish....thinking that there'll be a few extra microns of separation
from the dyed wood thanks to the epoxy coats....for cautious sanding.}
Added, "Imagine that minor sanding glitches of exposed bare wood could be toucht
up easily by passing a damp stain rag over the surface. Rub it dry, nobody notices."
Brian didn't like the idea because it can create weirdness wherever it gets into pores.
( he didn't use the word 'weirdness') But if a retouch is noticed in a particularly clear
bright finish, it'll be a....disaster. {But I'm thinking, tops of tiny peaks, not lakes.}
This method assumes that in sync with water dye, epoxy will bond to bare wood.
He suggested a variation: after staining is completed, fill the grain with AquaCoat.
Filler is 'credit carded', flat as possible, in two or three coats, with the least amount
of sanding necessary. {Very hard to estimate that - and attaining a flat surface is
absolutely necessary for a fine finish. So, the step has to be included in the system.
The dyed wood surface is right there under, but not under, the filler. Scarey.
Even if the prep is finessed by an artist, there'd be hardly anything to sand...even
lightly. The surface legitimately needs to be prepared for the next step... Epoxy.}
BUT, more importantly, if epoxy sealer here is put on top of a 'lesser' coating,
it's unable to bond to bare wood. Main purpose of epoxy is structural, not cosmetic.
well, that's my argument, and it may have given Brian a moment to agree with the
first method. But he can't give his 'blessing', that's my hook. Have to experiment.
Problem with our coamings is that they are NOT furniture. Like hand rails, rub rails,
even the companionway trim and drop boards... they have work to do, & perform.
.................................................. .................................................. ..............................
"How long will Epoxy survive sunlight" http://www.oneoceankayaks.com/Epoxtest.htm
Very well done study comparing 6 epoxies, by Vaclav Stejskal
............Anybody else think they might go the waterborne route??.............
'Traditional' varnish coating. No waterborne varnish No Bristol No polyurethane No
Cetol. (Clear coatings all burn in sun UV. Some get ugly - become a PITA to remove
or maintain. Ergo: oil varnish is not nice - except to look at - but more forgiving.)
.................................................. .................................................. ...................................
Degustatibus Non Disputandum
It's a matter of taste. Too bad that on a national scale disputes can't be settled over a
glass of brew. Sinbad, you'll have the bottom fermented, hopped 4.4 Czech Pilsner - served
in a chilled glass. I druther quaff from a wine goblet a dark top fermented Scotch ale with
low, or no hops, and a bang double yours at 8 or 9%.
We agree on one thing: little foam. I'm unable to drink grain anymore. You should feel
sorry for me. Thanks! But I did have a meal once at a white tablecloth restaurant, where
the only beer on the menu was an ice cold foreign Pilsner in a short bottle. A bit too
carbonated for my nose.... wasn't bad, wasn't bad at all. Actually had some taste!
HOW TO VARNISH
May have mentioned the following before: I've tried to locate the article, which appeared
of all places in National Fisherman, two or three decades ago! The article was headlined
something about this old pro east coast varnisher who breaks all the rules when it comes
to getting it on the wood. Photo showed him varnishing a gridiron wide mahogany stern,
or was it yellow pine, on a classic wooden lobster boat...Lost Claws - Nova Scotia (maybe).
Had him saying something a lot like your old boss.
Maybe he was your old boss! (Of course,I can't remember the quote)...Something like....
Just get it on any way it goes, don't matter. Don't worry about the foam, just slap it on.
Maybe thinned the first coat, maybe didn't...Then, stretch it out with your long strokes....
Can't add any more here without making something up.... but it obviously impressed me
that this pro got the coating on as quickly as possible....flattened it out....brushed it out
wide.....no BS....no mystery.
'Swing with it.' Rhythm has a lot to do with it.
Haven't done really any wide vertical surfaces. Recently heard that your last stokes
should be vertical. Horizontal leaves you open to sags - the gods don't forgive sags!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~
Later edit, 1/29/2017. ONLY ONE VARNISH RULES THEM ALL:
LE TONKINOIS.
WARN YOU! THIS PROCESS IS SO SIMPLE YOU'LL LIKE VARNISHING AGAIN. TONK
IS APPLIED 'OUT OF THE CAN' WITH NO THINNING ALLOWED. ROLL IT ON. TIP IT
OUT WITH FOAM. NO BRUSH CLEANING OR STORING. NO PETROLEUM. DECANT
INTO THE AMAZING STOP LOSS BAG. ALL VARNISHING PROBLEMS GONE!!!
What more do you want? No thinning solvent, no adding solvent. I've gotten a grand
piano finish using this "oil" that doesn't call itself a varnish. Ebb's method is to use
EpifanesMOLTOPREN micro-foam 4" rollers* (on a wire frame) and Jenny's** for
tipping (without wetting the foam) This means: no thinning allowed - no brush cleaning
and no solvents connected with that. No TOXIC products are used with this varnish.
220 aluminum grit sandpaper is not for sanding, but to lightly cut mini mountains off
(no dust making) -- then a rubdown with 3M maroon 7447 nylon pad . Dull surface.
Specifically this nylon pad only, because it has no added oil, wax or silicone product.
Varnish rolls on thin and even, without sagging, without curtains. With a nice mild
linseed aroma. LeTonk says epoxy primer not necessary. Without filling surface it'll
take 8-9 applications to create a mirror finish.
Repairs or recoat is normal, coating flattens and smoothes, repairs disappear.
Use a Wooster Pelican Pail*** that has liners and allows one handed roller loading
while rolling the coating, with the other. Magic.
Using StopLossBags (Duckworths), decanting Vernise#1**** out of its square can into
a clear plastic bag, that you squeeze air out to preserve the coating from skinover. It's
probably better, each opening of the varnish container, to pour what you intend to use
thru a cone filter. Job remains get saved. Bad idea. Because the varnish ends up with
these transparent jelly-globs, that must be strained out. Really shouldn't save air
exposed varnish from the pail, unless you're a cheapskate like me.
*SMS Distributors, http://www.smsdistributors.com/ {seems to be a one man
curmudgeon operation - you have to squeeze the order phone number out of him!! }
**JEN is a brand of wedge-tipped foam brush that has wood handles. Simply the best.
***Home Depot, Pelican imco is one of the best boat painting tools of all time!!
****American Rope and Tar, www.tarsmell.com/ {mom & pop)
DANCE OF THE GLOSSEER
As for varnishing wide surfaces: recently tonked Lit'lgull's new wide coamings, about
10x72 inches. 5 square feet... I'm used to wetting out short sections and tipping quickly,
then another short to tip into a wet edge. Multiple stop-n-goes. Did one side flat on the
bench and then the other side hanging from a frame. So that's 4 sides times 8, which is
32 sides. 160 sq ft!. Have to wait 24hrs each coat, before a lite prep.
Discovered something amazing for this stop & go varnisher:
Just rolled whole sides, and tipped end to end 4-5-6 times. drawing the wedge-tipped
foam with the grain whether flat or hanging vertically. Only once got curtains... knew
why and didn't make it happen again. The rollers (above) are made for this stuff, the
micro-foam fills up and releases evenly over the whole surface. Takes maybe a minute
and a half to roll a side!! Hardest part is tipping, walking forth and back, along the
coaming, trying to just touch not pull the varnish.
Fastest, nicest, most pleasant varnishing I've ever done!
CHEERS ! ! !